This article summarizes the non-drug treatment and therapy approaches known to us.
The (+) and (-) in the headings reflect our assessment of the benefits for ADHD.
In our experience, drug treatment is the most important and sensible form of therapy for severe and moderate forms of ADHD.
Among the thousands of people with ADHD that we got to know via the forum, those who thought that they had achieved sufficient symptom improvement with psychotherapy were not only clearly in the minority, but even more clearly: barely represented.
in our opinion, (suitable) ADHD medications deem effective (or suitable) are given an efficacy label of (+++++).
-
ADHD should definitely be treated with medication - at least temporarily - especially at the beginning of therapy.
People with ADHD who have never felt what it is like to live without these distressing symptoms cannot understand the goal of non-drug therapy from their own perception. Edel/Vollmoeller argue in a similar way. In addition, dopamine is a neurotrophic factor, which means that it is required for learning processes in the brain. The dopamine deficiency typical of ADHD therefore prevents learning success and should be remedied before psychotherapeutic treatment.
- A large meta-analysis of 190 studies involving 26,114 participants with ADHD found that stimulants appeared to be superior to behavioral therapy, cognitive training, and non-stimulants. Stimulants in combination with behavioral therapy appeared to be the most effective.
- Medications show a much greater Effect size on ADHD symptoms than non-pharmacological treatments.
- Presentation of the drug treatment at ⇒ Medication for ADHD - Overview.
Non-pharmacological treatments are important supportive measures which, in combination with medication, can lead to relevant additional improvements.
Psychoeducation, self-help groups, sports, psychotherapy, mindfulness techniques and neurofeedback are particularly noteworthy.
1. Non-drug therapy approaches for ADHD¶
1.1. Effective therapeutic approaches for ADHD (see individual articles)¶
For the effective forms of therapy, see the linked individual articles.
1.2. Therapeutic approaches for ADHD whose effect is not proven¶
1.2.1. Occupational therapy¶
The effectiveness of occupational therapy for ADHD is limited to the treatment of fine motor skills in preparation for school.
A study reports positive effects of equine-assisted occupational therapy for schoolchildren with ADHD.
1.2.2. Hemencephalography training¶
Effect not yet recognized, initial studies.
1.2.3. Self-instructions¶
Effect is disputed.
1.2.4. Listen to (classical) music to improve your mood¶
One study found that listening to Mozart for 10 minutes (Mozart piano sonata for four hands, KV 440) improved the mood of people with ADHD as well as people without ADHD, in contrast to subjects who listened to 10 minutes of silence. This does not prove an ADHD-specific treatment method.
However, music seems to be helpful for ADHD.
1.2.5. App-supported attention and organization training¶
One study reports that cell phone app-based training in attention and organization led to relevant improvements in a third of adults with ADHD.
A meta-analysis from 2019 found no further studies on the treatment of ADHD using specific apps
1.2.6. Organizational skills training¶
In SCT, training in organizational skills did not lead to any improvement in SCT symptoms from the perspective of the people with ADHD themselves. Only from the parents’ perspective were there improvements with an Effect size of approx. 0.5.
Parent assessments are highly susceptible to being biased towards desired outcomes. The greater the effort invested, the stronger this bias is.
1.2.7. Homework support¶
In the case of SCT, homework support did not lead to any improvement in SCT symptoms from the perspective of the people with ADHD themselves. Only from the parents’ perspective were there improvements with an Effect size of approx. 0.5.
Parent assessments are highly susceptible to being biased towards desired outcomes. This bias is all the stronger the greater the effort invested.
1.2.8. Social behavior training¶
A meta-analysis found no proven effect of non-drug training methods (coaching, etc.) in terms of improving social behavior towards peers.
A meta-analysis found weak evidence of benefits of peer-based interventions for ADHD, which are primarily aimed at strengthening social support among peers.
Another meta-analysis of 15 studies found evidence of moderate effectiveness of social skills training in children with ADHD.
1.2.9. Transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation¶
Transcutaneous auricular vagus nerve stimulation (taVNS) is a newly developed, non-invasive procedure. Stimulation of the cutaneous receptive field of the auricular branch of the vagus nerve in the outer ear is intended to activate the vagal connections to the central and peripheral nervous system.
One report cites transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation as a possible treatment for ADHD.
1.2.10. Acupuncture (?)¶
-
Positive results
- A meta-analysis reports a high effectiveness of acupuncture on hyperactivity
- A meta-analysis of k = 14 studies with n = 1,185 patients found that acupuncture as an adjunct to conventional medication supported the improvement of behavioral problems, learning problems, hyperactivity-impulsivity, and hyperactivity symptoms in ADHD patients, and as a sole treatment improved learning problems, hyperactivity-impulsivity, and hyperactivity symptoms in ADHD patients. The risk of bias in the included studies was generally concerning, so the evidence for the effectiveness of acupuncture for ADHD is currently too limited to recommend its use.
-
No improvements
- Another meta-analysis of 5 studies found no robust evidence that acupuncture improves ADHD.
Another meta-analysis intends to investigate the effect of acupuncture for the treatment of ADHD
The effectiveness of acupuncture is controversial. To date, there are no conclusive medical explanatory models.
- However, two German double-blind studies, which conclude that so far only a placebo effect can be proven for acupuncture, show in the figures that acupuncture achieved 20% better results compared to sham acupuncture
- Other studies report an effect that goes beyond placebo.
1.2.11. Homeopathy¶
A meta-analysis reports benefits of additional individual homeopathic treatment for ADHD. An RCT also reports symptom improvements through homeopathy, but only in parent reports.
1.2.12. Fidgets¶
One study observed significant improvement in sustained attention in students with ADHD who used Fidgets during class.
1.2.13. Random Noise¶
Random Noise treatment uses any form of energy (e.g. light, mechanical, electrical or acoustic energy) with unpredictable intensity to stimulate the brain and sensory receptors with the aim of improving sensory, motor and cognitive functions. Random Noise treatment originally used mechanical sounds for auditory and cutaneous stimuli. Today, electrical energy is increasingly used to stimulate the brain or skin. Recent evidence shows that transcranial random noise stimulation can increase corticospinal excitability, improve cognitive/motor performance and have positive after-effects on a behavioral and psychological level.
1.2.14. Spinal manipulation / spinal mobilization¶
A meta-analysis found no evidence of efficacy of spinal manipulation/mobilization for ADHD.
1.2.15. Ultrasound stimulation with low intensity¶
Low intensity ultrasound stimulation has been shown to improve abnormal brain function in SHR. We do not have studies on clinical ADHD treatment use in humans.
1.2.16. Quiet Eye Training¶
Source
1.2.17. Animal-assisted therapy¶
Source
1.3. Therapeutic approaches that are definitely ineffective¶
1.3.1. Phosphate diet (oats)¶
Find out more at ⇒ Nutrition and diet for ADHD
1.3.2. Certain Foods / food additives as sole causal cause of ADHD¶
There is no reliable evidence that certain foods or additives are responsible for ADHD.
However, food intolerances in general (in each case individually Incompatible substances) can lead to corresponding symptoms in the respective people with ADHD or increase the stress level in such a way that latent mental disorders (e.g. also ADHD) can appear or existing disorders can be exacerbated.
Find out more at ⇒ Nutrition and diet for ADHD
2. Multimodal therapy approach¶
Multimodal therapy is a combination of relevant treatment options. A combination of medication, psychotherapy and possibly other treatment options is used to treat ADHD. Multimodal treatment improves ADHD symptoms. However, this is not surprising. Only a comparison with purely psychotherapeutic and drug treatment would be relevant.
In adults with ADHD, combined treatment with medication and cognitive behavioral therapy was only superior to medication alone after the first 3 months. There was no difference after 6 and 9 months.
3. Treatment concepts, treatment manuals, guidelines¶
Source: Schmidt, Petermann
- Group therapy manual “Psychotherapy of ADHD in adults” (Hesslinger et al., 2004)
Adaptation of the Dialectical Behavioral Borderline Therapy concept to ADHD
- “Treatment manual for ADHD in adulthood” (Lauth, Minsel, 2009)
For individuals and groups
- “Psychoeducation and Coaching Manual ADHD in Adulthood” (D’Amelio et al., 2009),
Practical guidance on the treatment of ADHD and family groups
- “Training for ADD in adulthood (TADSE)” (Baer & Kirsch, 2010)
- “Cognitive behavioral therapy program for adult ADHD” (Safren et al., 2009)
Cognitive techniques for individual therapy
- Interdisciplinary evidence- and consensus-based (S3) guideline “ADHD in children, adolescents and adults”
4. Subtype-specific treatment¶
To date, few treatment concepts are known that differentiate between the various subtypes of ADHD - ADHD-HI and ADHD-C (with hyperactivity) on the one hand and ADHD-I (without hyperactivity) on the other.
In our opinion, ADHD-HI and ADHD-C suffer from the fact that the stress system of the HPA axis is permanently overactivated and is not shut down again due to an insufficient cortisol response to acute stress or insufficient addressability of the glucocorticoid receptors, while the ADHD-I subtype suffers from an over-intense neurotransmitter and stress hormone response to acute stress, which leads to a regular shutdown of the HPA axis due to the high cortisol response, but at the same time shuts down the PFC due to the parallel excessive release of noradrenaline, thereby triggering mental blocks and an inability to make decisions.
In our opinion, mindfulness is particularly important in ADHD-HI in order to achieve therapeutic ability in the first place. The permanently elevated stress level in ADHD-HI (with hyperactivity) is so strongly increased that mindfulness (MBCT, MBSR, meditation, yoga …) is downright aversive, which correlates with an inability to recover.
5. Multi-generational treatment for ADHD¶
Treating the children alone overlooks the fact that the influence of people with ADHD has a significant impact on the development of the children.
Treatment and support for mothers with ADHD showed positive Consequences for the children, whereby a higher intensity of treatment for mothers with ADHD (here: with DBT) only showed a temporary advantage for the children compared to less intensive treatment.
Children of mothers with high neuroticism and low conscientiousness should benefit more from behavioral therapies than other children. In contrast, children of mothers with medium neuroticism and medium conscientiousness or low neuroticism and high conscientiousness should benefit more from a multimodal treatment of therapy and medication or from medication alone than from behavioral therapy alone.
